Colonial Penn accepts credit card payments for life insurance premiums through their online portal, phone line, and mail

Colonial Penn, a life insurance company owned by CNL Lifestyle Properties, lets you pay your monthly or annual premiums using Visa, Mastercard, American Express, or Discover. You can set up a one-time payment or enroll in automatic recurring payments so your card is charged on your due date each month. The company does not charge a fee for credit card payments, though your card issuer may treat the transaction as a cash advance or purchase depending on how they classify insurance payments.

The fastest way to pay is through Colonial Penn's online account portal at colonialpen.com. You log in with your policy number and create a payment using your card details. If you do not have an online account, you can call Colonial Penn's customer service line at 1-800-523-5734 to make a payment over the phone with a representative. You can also mail a check, but that takes longer and does not use your credit card.

Key Takeaways

  • Colonial Penn accepts Visa, Mastercard, American Express, and Discover for premium payments with no fee from the company itself.
  • The online portal at colonialpen.com is the fastest way to pay and lets you set up automatic monthly charges to your card.
  • Phone payments through 1-800-523-5734 work if you do not have online access, though a representative will need your policy and card information.
  • Your credit card issuer may classify the payment as a cash advance rather than a purchase, which could trigger different interest rates or fees.

Paying online through your Colonial Penn account

Log into your account at colonialpen.com using your policy number and password. If you have not created an online account yet, you will need to register with your policy number, date of birth, and email address. Once logged in, look for the "Pay My Bill" or "Make a Payment" option in your account dashboard.

Enter your credit card number, expiration date, and CVV. You can choose to pay the full amount due or a partial payment. Colonial Penn will show you the payment date and confirmation number before you submit. After you confirm, you will see a receipt on screen and receive an email confirmation. The payment typically posts to your account within one to two business days.

If you want to avoid logging in each month, you can set up automatic recurring payments during this process. Select the option to charge your card on the same date each month, and Colonial Penn will process the payment without you having to return to the site. You can change or cancel automatic payments anytime through your account settings.

Paying by phone with a Colonial Penn representative

Call Colonial Penn customer service at 1-800-523-5734 during business hours. A representative will ask for your policy number and verify your identity by asking for your date of birth or the last four digits of your Social Security number. Have your credit card ready with the card number, expiration date, and CVV available.

The representative will tell you the amount due and the date the payment will post. They will process the charge and give you a confirmation number. Write down this number for your records. The payment will appear in your account within one to two business days, just as it would online.

Phone payments are useful if you do not have internet access, prefer speaking to a person, or need to discuss your account at the same time. However, calling takes longer than paying online, and you have to wait for business hours. Colonial Penn's phone lines may have wait times during peak periods.

How your credit card issuer may treat the payment

When you pay an insurance premium with a credit card, your card issuer classifies the transaction in one of two ways: as a purchase or as a cash advance. This matters because cash advances typically carry higher interest rates than purchases, sometimes 3 to 5 percentage points higher. Cash advances also usually start accruing interest when ready, with no grace period, whereas purchases often have a 21-day grace period before interest kicks in.

Most card issuers treat insurance payments as purchases, which is the better outcome for you. However, some issuers classify them as cash advances. You can check your card's terms or call your issuer's customer service line to ask how they will treat a Colonial Penn payment before you make it. If your issuer treats it as a cash advance, you may want to pay by bank account transfer or check instead to avoid the higher interest rate.

Even if the payment is classified as a purchase, using a credit card to pay an insurance bill means you are borrowing money from your card issuer until you pay your bill. If you carry a balance, the interest you pay on that balance may exceed any rewards you earn from the transaction. Pay off the charge in full by your due date to avoid interest.

Rewards and cash back on insurance payments

Some credit cards earn rewards or cash back on insurance payments, but many do not. Cards that focus on travel, dining, or gas often exclude insurance from their bonus categories. Cards with flat-rate cash back on all purchases (typically 1 to 2 percent) will earn rewards on your Colonial Penn payment, but the amount is modest.

Before you decide to pay your insurance premium with a credit card to earn rewards, calculate whether the rewards are worth the risk. If your card charges an annual fee, the fee may be higher than the cash back you earn on a single insurance payment. If your card issuer treats the payment as a cash advance, the higher interest rate will quickly erase any rewards value.

A better use of a rewards card is to charge everyday purchases like groceries or gas, then use the cash back or points to offset your insurance payment indirectly. This way you earn rewards on spending you would do anyway, without the risk of the insurance payment being classified as a cash advance.

What to do if your payment does not post

If you made a payment online or by phone but do not see it in your account after two business days, log back into your Colonial Penn account and check the payment history section. This will show all payments received, including the date and amount. If the payment appears there, it has posted and you can disregard any late notices.

If the payment does not appear in your account history after two business days, call Colonial Penn at 1-800-523-5734 with your confirmation number. A representative can look up the payment in their system and tell you whether it was received. If it was received but not yet posted, they can note your account so you are not charged a late fee. If it was not received, the representative can help you resubmit the payment or investigate what went wrong with your card.

Keep your confirmation number and email receipt for at least 30 days after making a payment. If a dispute arises, these documents prove you paid on time. If your card issuer later disputes the charge, you can provide the confirmation number to Colonial Penn as proof the payment was authorized.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Colonial Penn charge a fee to pay with a credit card?

No. Colonial Penn does not charge a fee for credit card payments made online or by phone. However, your credit card issuer may charge a fee if they classify the payment as a cash advance. Check your card's terms or call your issuer before paying to confirm there will be no fee.

Can I set up automatic credit card payments for my Colonial Penn policy?

Yes. During the online payment process, you can choose to have your card charged automatically on the same date each month. You can change or cancel automatic payments anytime through your account settings without calling customer service.

What credit cards does Colonial Penn accept?

Colonial Penn accepts Visa, Mastercard, American Express, and Discover. They do not accept other payment methods like PayPal or digital wallets through their online portal, though you can ask a phone representative whether other options are available.

How long does it take for a credit card payment to show up on my Colonial Penn account?

Payments typically post within one to two business days. If you pay on a Friday, the payment may not appear until Monday or Tuesday. If you are close to your due date, pay at least three business days early to may support the payment posts on time.

What should I do if my credit card payment is declined?

Check that your card number, expiration date, and CVV are entered correctly. If the information is correct, your card may have insufficient funds, be expired, or be flagged by your issuer for fraud. Contact your card issuer to ask why the payment was declined, then try again once the issue is resolved. You can also call Colonial Penn to pay by phone with a different card.