What the Amex Everyday Preferred offers and who should consider it
The American Express Everyday Preferred is a cash-back card that rewards everyday purchases at higher rates than most competing cards, but charges an annual fee of $95. You earn 3X points per dollar on the first $6,000 you spend at US supermarkets each year (then 1X after that), 3X on gas stations and transit, and 1X on everything else. Points convert to cash back at a fixed rate: one point equals one cent, so 100 points equals $1.
The card makes sense if you spend heavily at supermarkets or gas stations and can absorb the annual fee through rewards. A household that spends $500 monthly at supermarkets alone generates $180 in annual cash back from that category alone, which covers most of the fee. If you rarely use supermarkets or gas stations, the flat 1X rate on other purchases does not offset the $95 cost — a no-annual-fee card like the Chase Freedom Unlimited or Capital One SavorOne would be cheaper.
Amex also offers a no-fee version called the Everyday (without "Preferred"), which earns 1X on supermarkets and gas and 1X on everything else. The Preferred version is worth the fee only if the higher supermarket and gas rates matter to your actual spending.
Key Takeaways
- The card earns 3X points at US supermarkets (up to $6,000 per year, then 1X), 3X at gas stations and transit, and 1X everywhere else, with points worth one cent each.
- The $95 annual fee requires roughly $9,500 in annual supermarket and gas spending to break even, depending on your mix of categories.
- Amex Everyday Preferred does not offer a sign-up bonus, so you build rewards only through ongoing spending.
- The card works best for households with consistent supermarket and gas expenses; occasional users should compare it to no-fee alternatives.
- Amex cards are accepted at fewer merchants than Visa or Mastercard, so confirm your regular stores and gas stations take Amex before explore.
How the supermarket and gas rewards actually work
The 3X supermarket rate applies only to purchases at US supermarkets coded as supermarkets by the merchant's payment processor. Warehouse clubs like Costco and Sam's Club, convenience stores, and gas stations attached to supermarkets do not count. If you shop primarily at Whole Foods, Kroger, Safeway, or regional chains, the rate applies. If you split shopping between a supermarket and a warehouse club, only the supermarket portion earns 3X.
The $6,000 annual cap resets on your card's anniversary date, not the calendar year. Once you hit $6,000 in supermarket purchases in a year, every supermarket purchase after that earns 1X for the rest of the year. Tracking this yourself is necessary — Amex does not alert you when you approach the cap. Many cardholders miss the threshold and spend months earning 1X without realizing it.
Gas stations earn 3X regardless of how much you spend, with no annual cap. Transit purchases — subway, bus, taxi, rideshare, parking, trains, and tolls — also earn 3X with no limit. If you use public transit regularly or drive frequently, this category can generate substantial rewards.
Annual fee and whether the rewards offset it
The $95 fee posts on your anniversary date each year. Amex does not waive it for low-spending cardholders, and there is no way to downgrade to the no-fee Everyday card without closing the account and reapplying (which resets your credit history with Amex).
To break even, you need rewards equal to $95 annually. The math depends on your spending mix. If you spend $500 monthly at supermarkets ($6,000 per year), you earn $180 in cash back from that category alone (3X on $6,000 = 18,000 points = $180). Add gas and transit, and most households exceed $95 easily. But if you spend $200 monthly at supermarkets ($2,400 per year) and rarely use gas or transit, you earn only $72 from supermarkets plus a small amount from other purchases — likely not enough to justify the fee.
Use this framework: multiply your monthly supermarket spending by 12, then multiply by 0.02 (the 2% advantage over a 1X card). If that number exceeds $95, the card pays for itself through supermarkets alone. Add gas and transit rewards on top.
No sign-up bonus and how this card compares to alternatives
The Everyday Preferred does not offer a sign-up bonus. You earn rewards only on purchases you make after approval. This is a significant difference from competing cards like the Chase Sapphire Preferred (which offers a sign-up bonus worth $500 to $750 in value) or the Capital One Venture X (which offers $500 in travel credit). If a sign-up bonus matters to your decision, this card does not provide one.
Compared to the no-fee Everyday card from Amex, the Preferred version costs $95 more per year but earns 2X additional points at supermarkets and gas (3X instead of 1X). The no-fee version makes sense if you want Amex acceptance and rewards but do not spend enough in high-earning categories to justify the fee.
Compared to cards from other issuers, the Everyday Preferred competes most directly with the Chase Freedom Unlimited (no annual fee, 1.5X on all purchases) and the Capital One SavorOne (no annual fee, 3X at supermarkets and restaurants, 1X elsewhere). Both are cheaper if you do not spend heavily at supermarkets. The Everyday Preferred wins only if Amex acceptance at your regular stores matters and you spend enough to offset the fee.
Amex acceptance and where the card works
American Express is accepted at fewer merchants than Visa or Mastercard, particularly at smaller retailers, gas stations, and regional chains. Before explore, check whether your regular supermarket, gas station, and frequent merchants accept Amex. Many independent gas stations, small grocers, and regional chains do not.
Large chains like Whole Foods, Kroger, Safeway, Target, Walmart, and most major gas station brands accept Amex. But if you shop at a local market or fill up at an independent station, confirm acceptance first. You can search the Amex merchant locator on their website or call the merchant directly.
If Amex is not accepted at your primary supermarket or gas station, the card's high earning rates become irrelevant — you cannot use it where you spend the most. In that case, a Visa or Mastercard with similar rewards rates would be more practical.
Other card features and protections
The Everyday Preferred includes standard Amex protections: purchase protection (covers items damaged or stolen within 90 days), return protection (Amex refunds you if a merchant refuses a return within 90 days), and extended warranty (adds one year to manufacturer warranties). These are common on premium cards but not unique to Amex.
The card does not offer travel benefits like airport lounge access, travel insurance, or statement credits. It is a straightforward cash-back card without the perks that come with higher-fee Amex cards like the Gold or Platinum. If you travel frequently and want lounge access or travel protections, a different card would be more valuable.
Amex also offers a feature called "Amex Offers," which are discounts or cash back at specific merchants that you set up in your online account. These change monthly and vary by cardholder. Some are valuable (10% back at certain restaurants), others are not (a $5 discount on a $50 purchase). Check what offers are available to you before explore, though offers are not may provide to continue.
How to decide if this card belongs in your wallet
Start by calculating your annual supermarket and gas spending. If you spend less than $3,000 per year combined at supermarkets and gas stations, the card does not pay for itself. If you spend $3,000 to $6,000, the card likely breaks even or slightly exceeds the fee. If you spend more than $6,000 at supermarkets (remember the $6,000 cap) plus regular gas and transit, the card generates meaningful rewards.
Next, confirm that Amex is accepted at your primary supermarket and gas station. If it is not, stop here — the card's value disappears. If it is, move to the third step: compare the rewards rate to a no-fee alternative. The Chase Freedom Unlimited earns 1.5X on all purchases with no fee. The Everyday Preferred earns 3X at supermarkets and gas but costs $95. That $95 gap requires roughly $4,750 in supermarket and gas spending to close (at a 2% advantage). If you spend less than that, the no-fee card is cheaper.
Finally, consider whether you want to carry an Amex card at all. If you already have a primary card that works everywhere, adding an Amex means carrying two cards or deciding which to use at each transaction. Some people prefer one card that works everywhere over two cards with different acceptance. That is a personal choice, but it matters to the card's actual usefulness.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does the Everyday Preferred have a sign-up bonus?
No. The card does not offer a sign-up bonus, so you earn rewards only on purchases after approval. If a sign-up bonus is important to your decision, other cards like the Chase Sapphire Preferred or Capital One Venture X offer bonuses worth $500 or more in value.
What happens if I do not spend $6,000 at supermarkets in a year?
You still earn 3X on whatever you spend, up to $6,000. If you spend $3,000 at supermarkets, you earn 3X on all $3,000. The cap only affects spending above $6,000, which then earns 1X for the rest of the year.
Can I use this card at Costco or Sam's Club?
Costco and Sam's Club are warehouse clubs, not supermarkets, so they do not earn the 3X supermarket rate. They earn 1X like any other purchase. You would earn 3X only at traditional supermarkets coded as such by the payment processor.
Is the $95 annual fee worth it if I only shop at supermarkets?
Only if you spend at least $4,750 per year at supermarkets. At $4,750, you earn $95 in rewards (3X on $4,750 = 14,250 points = $142.50, minus the $95 fee = $47.50 net gain). Below that threshold, a no-fee card is cheaper.
What if my supermarket does not accept American Express?
The card becomes much less valuable, since you cannot earn the 3X rate at your primary spending location. You would earn only 1X on supermarket purchases made with a different card, and only 3X on gas and transit. In that case, a Visa or Mastercard with a flat 1.5% or 2% rate would likely be more practical.