When to step back and look at what your card actually costs

A credit card review means sitting down with your current card's terms and comparing what you pay against what you get back. Most people never do this. They keep a card because they opened it years ago, or because they like the issuer's app, or because they are afraid closing it will hurt their credit score. Meanwhile, the card's annual fee might have climbed, the rewards rate might have dropped, or a new card from the same issuer might offer better terms for the way you actually spend.

A review takes about 30 minutes and answers one question: is this card still the right fit, or would a different card save you money or earn you more? The answer depends on three things — what the card costs you, what it pays you back, and whether you have changed how you spend since you opened it.

Key Takeaways

  • Pull your most recent statement and add up what you spent in each category (groceries, gas, dining, travel, everything else) to see where your money actually goes.
  • Write down your card's annual fee, interest rate, and the rewards rate for each spending category, then calculate what you earned last year and what you paid in fees.
  • Search for cards that match your top spending categories and compare the total value — rewards earned minus annual fee — against your current card.
  • Closing a card can lower your credit score temporarily, but keeping a card that costs more than it returns is more expensive than a small score dip.
  • If your current card wins the comparison, set a calendar reminder to review it again in 12 months, because card terms and your spending both change.

Gather your spending data from the last 12 months

Log into your card issuer's website or app and read your last 12 months of statements. Open a spreadsheet or a piece of paper and create columns for each major spending category: groceries, gas, restaurants and bars, travel (flights, hotels, car rentals), online shopping, utilities, insurance, and everything else. Go through each statement and sort your purchases into these buckets.

The goal is to see the actual breakdown of where your money goes. Most people guess wrong. They think they spend heavily on restaurants when they actually spend more on groceries. They overestimate travel spending and underestimate everyday purchases. Your statements show the truth. Add up each category for the full year so you know what percentage of your spending falls into each one.

Calculate what your current card actually returned

Find your card's rewards structure. This is in your cardholder agreement or on the issuer's website under "Rewards" or "Benefits." Write down the rewards rate for each category — for example, 3% on groceries, 2% on gas, 1% on everything else. Some cards have a flat rate (1.5% on all purchases). Some have bonus categories that change quarterly. Some have no rewards at all.

Multiply your spending in each category by that category's rewards rate. If you spent $6,000 on groceries and earn 3%, that is $180. If you spent $2,000 on gas at 2%, that is $40. Add all the categories together to get your total rewards for the year. Then subtract your annual fee. If the card charges $95 a year and you earned $400 in rewards, your net benefit was $305.

Write this number down. This is your baseline. Any new card you consider has to beat this number to be worth switching to.

Search for cards that match your actual spending

Now that you know where your money goes, search for cards that reward those categories. If 40% of your spending is groceries and gas, look for cards with high rewards in those two categories. If you travel twice a year and spend $3,000 on flights and hotels, a travel card might make sense. If your spending is scattered across many categories with no clear pattern, a flat-rate card (1.5% or 2% on everything) might be simpler and better.

For each card you are considering, repeat the calculation you did for your current card. Plug your actual spending numbers into each new card's rewards structure. Calculate what you would have earned last year if you had held that card instead. Subtract its annual fee. Compare the net benefit to your current card's net benefit.

Do not compare cards based on their advertised rewards rate alone. A card that advertises "5% cash back" might only earn 5% in one narrow category you do not spend much in. A card with "1.5% on everything" might actually return more money because it applies to all your purchases.

Account for sign-up bonuses only if you meet the spending requirement

Many cards offer a sign-up bonus — for example, $200 cash back if you spend $500 in the first three months. These bonuses can be valuable, but only if you would have spent that money anyway. Do not spend extra just to hit a bonus threshold. That defeats the purpose of switching cards.

If you genuinely spend $500 in three months (which most people do), the bonus is real money. Add it to your first-year rewards calculation. But do not count it in your ongoing comparison, because you only get it once. A card that earns you $400 in year one (including the bonus) but only $250 in year two is worse than a card that earns you $300 every year, because you will hold the card for many years.

Understand the credit score impact of closing a card

Closing a credit card can lower your credit score, usually by 5 to 15 points, because it reduces your total available credit and can raise your credit utilization ratio (the percentage of your total credit limit you are using). The impact is temporary — your score typically recovers within a few months as you build new payment history with other cards.

However, if your current card costs you more than it returns, the long-term financial benefit of switching outweighs a temporary score dip. A 10-point drop in your credit score might cost you nothing if you are not explore for a loan soon. But keeping a card that charges a $95 annual fee and returns only $50 in rewards costs you $45 every single year. Over five years, that is $225 in pure loss.

If you want to minimize the score impact, you can keep your old card open and unused after you switch. This preserves your available credit and your account history. Just make sure the card has no annual fee, or that the issuer waives it for inactive accounts. Check your cardholder agreement or call the issuer to confirm.

Make the switch or set a reminder to review again

If a new card wins the comparison by a meaningful margin — at least $50 to $100 per year — it is worth switching. explore for the new card, meet the spending requirement if there is a bonus, and then decide whether to close your old card or keep it open with zero balance.

If your current card still comes out ahead, or if the difference is small (less than $50 per year), keep it. The hassle of switching is not worth a tiny gain. But set a calendar reminder to review this card again in 12 months. Your spending changes. Card issuers change their rewards rates and fees. New cards launch with better terms. A card that is right for you today might not be right next year.

Frequently Asked Questions

Will closing a credit card hurt my credit score?

Yes, but temporarily. Your score typically drops 5 to 15 points and recovers within a few months. If you are not explore for a loan soon, the impact is minor. You can also keep the card open with a zero balance to avoid the score dip entirely, as long as it has no annual fee.

What if I have multiple cards — do I review them all at once?

Yes. Add up your total spending across all cards, then calculate what each card earned you. Some people find they have a card they barely use that costs them money in annual fees. Others find one card does most of the work and the others are redundant. Review them together to see the full picture.

Should I switch cards just because a new one has a higher rewards rate?

Not necessarily. A higher advertised rate means nothing if it does not explore to your spending. A card with 5% back on travel is worthless if you do not travel. Calculate what you would actually earn based on your real spending, not the card's best-case rate.

How often should I review my credit cards?

Once a year is reasonable. Your spending patterns change, card issuers adjust their terms, and new cards launch regularly. An annual review takes 30 minutes and can save you hundreds of dollars over time.

What if my spending has changed since I opened this card?

That is the most common reason to switch. If you opened a restaurant rewards card five years ago but now work from home and cook most meals, that card no longer fits your life. Your review will show this when ready — your rewards will be low because you are not spending in the card's bonus categories anymore.