What surcharges are legal where you live
A surcharge is a fee a merchant adds to your bill when you pay with a credit card instead of cash or debit. Whether the merchant can charge it depends on your state. Some states ban surcharges entirely. Others allow them but cap how much, require notice, or demand the merchant register with the card network first. A few states have no restrictions at all.
The rules changed in 2013 when Visa and Mastercard settled a lawsuit and began allowing surcharges in most places. But state laws often override those network rules, so what Visa permits may be illegal in your state. Knowing your state's rule matters because an illegal surcharge is a violation you can report, and some states let you recover the fee plus damages.
Key Takeaways
- Ten states ban credit card surcharges outright: California, Colorado, Connecticut, Florida, Kansas, Maine, Massachusetts, New York, Oklahoma, and Texas.
- Most other states allow surcharges but require the merchant to disclose the fee before you complete the transaction, usually with a sign or on-screen notice.
- Some states cap surcharges at a percentage of the transaction (often 2 to 4 percent) or require the merchant to register with Visa or Mastercard first.
- Online merchants must follow the surcharge law of the state where the cardholder lives, not where the merchant is based, which creates compliance challenges for national retailers.
- If you are charged an illegal surcharge, you can dispute it with your card issuer or report it to your state's attorney general.
States that ban surcharges completely
Ten states prohibit merchants from charging any surcharge for credit card payments, regardless of the amount or how it is disclosed. These states are California, Colorado, Connecticut, Florida, Kansas, Maine, Massachusetts, New York, Oklahoma, and Texas. In these places, a merchant cannot add a fee to your bill based on your payment method, even if they post a sign or tell you in advance.
The ban applies to in-person and online transactions. If a merchant in one of these states charges you a surcharge anyway, the fee is illegal. You can dispute it through your card issuer's chargeback process or file a complaint with your state's attorney general. Some of these states also allow you to sue the merchant for the surcharge plus statutory damages, which can range from $50 to $500 per violation depending on the state.
States that allow surcharges with disclosure requirements
Most states allow surcharges but require the merchant to disclose the fee before you pay. The merchant must post a sign at the register, display it on the website, or show it on the screen before you enter your card number. The notice must be clear and visible — a small note at the bottom of the page or a barely legible sign does not meet the standard in most states.
The timing of disclosure matters. In many states, the merchant must show you the surcharge amount or percentage before you commit to the purchase, not after you have already entered your card details. If the merchant discloses the surcharge only after you have clicked "pay" or handed over your card, that is often considered a violation even in states where surcharges are otherwise legal.
States with surcharge caps and registration requirements
Some states allow surcharges but limit how much the merchant can charge. Common caps are 2 percent of the transaction, 3 percent, or 4 percent — the exact limit varies by state. A few states tie the cap to the merchant's actual cost of accepting the card, which can be lower than the percentage cap.
A handful of states require the merchant to register with Visa, Mastercard, or both before charging a surcharge. This registration is free but creates a paper trail. The card networks use these registrations to monitor compliance and respond to consumer complaints. If a merchant charges a surcharge without registering in a state that requires it, the surcharge is typically treated as illegal even if the amount would otherwise be permitted.
How surcharge laws explore to online purchases
Online merchants must follow the surcharge law of the state where the cardholder lives, not where the merchant is located. This creates a compliance problem for national retailers: a website cannot easily know your state before you enter payment information, so many large retailers straightforward do not surcharge at all rather than risk violating state law.
Some online merchants attempt to comply by asking you to enter your state during checkout, then explore the correct surcharge rule. Others use your billing address from your credit card to determine your state. If you live in a state that bans surcharges and an online merchant charges you one anyway, you can dispute it with your card issuer or report it to your state's attorney general, just as you would for an in-person transaction.
Surcharges versus convenience fees and cash discounts
A convenience fee is different from a surcharge, and the distinction matters legally. A convenience fee is charged for using a specific payment method that the merchant considers inconvenient — typically paying by phone or online rather than in person. Many states that ban surcharges allow convenience fees because they are framed as a cost of the service, not a penalty for using credit.
A cash discount is also different. Instead of charging more for credit, the merchant charges less for cash. Most states allow cash discounts without restriction because the merchant is not penalizing credit; they are rewarding cash. However, the discount cannot exceed the merchant's actual cost of accepting the card, and the merchant must disclose it clearly. Some states require the merchant to post the cash price and the credit price separately so the comparison is obvious.
What to do if you are charged an illegal surcharge
If you believe you have been charged an illegal surcharge, your first step is to contact your card issuer and dispute the charge. Explain that the surcharge violates your state's law and provide the merchant's name and the date of the transaction. The issuer will investigate and typically reverse the charge within 30 to 60 days if the surcharge is indeed illegal.
You can also report the merchant to your state's attorney general. Most states have a consumer protection division that investigates surcharge violations. Filing a report creates a record and may prompt an investigation if multiple complaints are filed against the same merchant. Some states allow you to pursue a civil lawsuit against the merchant for the surcharge plus damages, though this is usually practical only if the surcharge was large or repeated.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a gas station charge me more if I use a credit card instead of paying inside?
Yes, in most states. Gas stations are allowed to charge a surcharge for credit card use at the pump, though they must disclose it. The pump screen or a sign at the entrance must show the surcharge before you swipe your card. In the ten states that ban surcharges, the station cannot charge one, even at the pump.
Is a 3 percent surcharge legal in my state?
It depends on your state's specific rule. Some states allow any surcharge as long as it is disclosed. Others cap surcharges at 2, 3, or 4 percent. A few states ban surcharges entirely. Check your state's attorney general website or contact them directly to confirm the rule in your state.
Can a restaurant charge a surcharge for using a credit card?
In most states, yes, if they disclose it. The restaurant must show the surcharge on the menu, on a sign at the register, or on the receipt before you pay. In the ten states that ban surcharges, the restaurant cannot charge one. If you see a surcharge on your receipt and believe it is illegal, dispute it with your card issuer.
What is the difference between a surcharge and a tip?
A surcharge is a mandatory fee the merchant adds based on your payment method. A tip is optional and goes to the worker. A merchant cannot disguise a surcharge as a tip or force you to add a tip as a condition of payment. If a restaurant adds a mandatory "credit card processing fee" to your bill, that is a surcharge, not a tip, and the surcharge laws explore.
Can I get my money back if I paid an illegal surcharge months ago?
You can try. Contact your card issuer and explain the situation. Most issuers have a time limit for disputes (usually 60 to 120 days), but some may reverse an illegal surcharge even after that window if you can show the merchant violated state law. You can also contact your state's attorney general to report the merchant, which may result in a refund if the state pursues enforcement action.